There’s a shared, almost secret ritual among gamers. It happens when a digital storefront flashes a “-75%” sale banner, or when we see that one title, the one we’ve had our eye on for months, finally dip below a psychological price point. We click “Purchase.” A warm, fleeting thrill of acquisition washes over us. The game downloads, its icon appearing proudly in our library… and then it sits there. It joins the silent, digital congregation of other titles with “0 minutes played.” We’ve just fed the beast: the gaming backlog.
If you see yourself in this scene, you are far from alone. This isn’t a minor habit; it’s a defining feature of modern gaming culture. Industry data reveals a startling truth: a significant majority of players never see the end of the games they start. For sprawling titles like Assassin’s Creed Valhalla (61 hours to complete) or even the critically adored Baldur’s Gate 3 (68 hours), completion rates can hover between just 15% and 22%. We are collectively buying more than we could possibly play, turning our libraries from sources of joy into sources of low-grade anxiety.
Why do we do this? And more importantly, how can we break free from the cycle and rediscover the simple pleasure of play?
Why Our Libraries Outpace Our Lives
The backlog phenomenon isn’t a personal failing; it’s a perfect storm of psychology, design, and modern life. On a fundamental level, we are wired to seek out new opportunities. Psychologically, we love having options, believing more choices will lead to greater satisfaction. A vast library feels like a treasure trove of potential fun. This is compounded by “social comparison.” In online communities, a massive game collection can become a badge of honor, a measure of our dedication to the hobby, even if we never play half of it.
The games industry itself has evolved in a way that feeds this cycle. Over the last two decades, AAA game budgets and development times have ballooned, often resulting in longer, denser worlds designed to deliver “value” through sheer volume. Yet, this has reached a point of diminishing returns. As one industry report notes, “bigger is not always better, and a full experience does not necessarily mean more icons on the map”. When faced with an 80-hour open-world epic, many time-strapped players simply stall out.
And time is the ultimate bottleneck. The average gamer is now 37 years old. We’re navigating careers, relationships, and responsibilities that our teenage selves, who could lose whole weekends to a single game, never imagined. Our leisure time is fragmented and precious. When a game starts to feel like a second job—demanding grind or committing to a narrative longer than a novel series—it’s easy to quietly step away, chasing the quicker, more accessible hit of a new purchase or a live-service game.
The Emotional Weight of the Unfinished
What starts as a collection can subtly morph into a psychological burden. That backlog tab stops being a gallery of future adventures and starts feeling like a to-do list, a monument to our own impulsivity. This is where anxiety creeps in. A nagging voice asks, “Will I ever have time for all of these?” In extreme cases, this can even tap into a deeper, more existential fear—the reminder that our time is finite.
This mindset turns gaming from a hobby into an obligation. We might start a new game not out of genuine excitement, but out of a grim sense of duty to “clear the backlog.” This is the opposite of why we play games. As one writer who chronicled his journey to “backlog zero” discovered, the key was learning to stop whenever a game became “more work than play”. The goal is enjoyment, not completion for its own sake.
Importantly, we need to separate common backlog guilt from genuine problem gaming. Clinical research into gaming disorders focuses not on the number of hours played or games owned, but on significant distress or dysfunction—the jeopardizing of relationships, careers, or personal well-being. For the vast majority, a backlog is a manageable habit, not a disorder. The challenge is managing the habit before the mild anxiety it causes starts to spoil the fun.
How Do We Fix This? Moving from Guilt to Intention
Fixing the backlog problem isn’t about a ruthless, joyless purge. It’s about changing our relationship with our games from one of ownership to one of experience. Here are a few thoughtful strategies, drawn from gamers who’ve been in the trenches.
First, get to know your backlog. Create a simple list or use a free tracking tool like HowLongToBeat or Backloggd to see what you actually own. Just the act of cataloging can be revealing. Then, be strategic. Some advocate the “two games out, one game in” rule: you can’t buy a new game until you’ve finished (or mindfully abandoned) two from your backlog. This simple rule forces conscious choice over impulse.
Second, redefine what “finishing” means. Not every game deserves a 100% completionist run. For many, the 15-hour core story of a 60-hour RPG is a complete and satisfying experience. As game developer Jason VandenBerghe argues, putting down a controller before the final credits isn’t a sin against the art form; it’s an intrinsic part of it. Give yourself permission to enjoy a chapter of a game and then move on.
Third, curate your intake. Be brutally honest with new purchases. One effective mindset shift is to ask yourself: “Do I want to play this more than any other game I already own?” This is a much higher bar than the sale-driven question of “Do I want this?”. Utilize wishlists and price trackers, and consider subscription services like Xbox Game Pass or Humble Choice for trying new releases without the permanent commitment of a purchase.
Finally, and most crucially, play with purpose, not pressure. Schedule short, dedicated gaming sessions. Mix up genres to avoid burnout—palate cleansers like a short indie game between RPG marathons can work wonders. Play games to connect with friends or unwind, not to tick a box. When a game feels like a slog, walk away. You can always return later if curiosity calls.
A New Playthrough
The backlog, in the end, is a symptom of abundance. We are lucky to live in an era with such an incredible wealth of interactive stories and worlds. The fix isn’t to shun this abundance, but to engage with it more thoughtfully.
Let’s stop seeing our unplayed games as a mark of guilt and start seeing them for what they are: a library of possibilities. Some we will dive into and love. Some we will sample and set aside. Others will remain on the shelf, and that’s perfectly okay. The goal is not to reach a mythical “backlog zero,” but to ensure that every minute we spend playing is chosen, not chore-like.
The next time you’re scrolling through your library, feeling that familiar pang of indecision, try this: ignore the hours-to-complete, ignore the critical ratings. Ask the simplest, most human question: “What do I feel like playing right now?” Then press start, and let the rest go.
Other Articles
The Joy of Shared Worlds: Finding Games Your Non-Gamer Partner Will Love
No Comment! Be the first one.